facebookpixel
Homeowner comparing three written moving estimates

Choose a Moving Company: Get 3 Written Estimates, Not Phone Quotes

Start by defining your move in detail, then get at least three written, comparable estimates, preferably from a mover who inspects your home in person or reviews a full inventory before quoting. Favor the company that documents scope, valuation coverage, payment terms, and claims procedures clearly in writing, including a signed estimate and a bill of lading. The rest of this guide walks through exactly how to do each step.


Summary:

  • Give every mover the same room by room inventory, access details, dates, and packing needs; accept written estimates only after an inspection or inventory review.
  • A binding estimate locks the price unless you add items or services; a nonbinding estimate can reach 110% at delivery under federal rules.
  • For interstate moves, verify the mover’s U.S. DOT number against its name; intrastate licensing rules vary, so check your state consumer office.
  • Walk away from blank paperwork, cash only demands, or large deposits, and get valuation terms, accepted payment methods, inventory, and claims steps in writing.
  • Choose labor help or a self service container to cut costs when you can manage loading and transport; otherwise, full service covers the entire move.

Caseys Movers
Plan Your Portland Move With Care
Caseys Movers provides tailored local and long-distance moves, with one truck and one crew for personalized attention throughout the process.

Visit Caseys Movers

Table of Contents

Define your move and the services you actually need

Not every move needs the same kind of help, and the category you fall into changes which companies you should even be calling. A studio apartment move across town is a different job than a cross-country relocation with a baby grand piano, and movers who specialize in one may not be equipped for the other.

The FMCSA’s guidance on selecting a mover breaks moves into categories that matter for licensing and estimating: local, long-distance or interstate, international, apartment, senior, office or commercial, packing-only, labor-only, storage, and specialty item handling. Interstate moves carry federal requirements that local moves do not, and international moves add customs and maritime rules on top of that. Knowing your category before you call anyone narrows your search to companies that actually do that work regularly.

Once you know the category, describe the job the same way to every company you contact. A consistent description is what makes three estimates comparable instead of three unrelated numbers.

  • List every room and its contents, including closets, garage, and attic.
  • Note stairs, elevators, and how far the truck will have to park from the door.
  • Flag anything oversized or fragile: pianos, safes, artwork, aquariums.
  • Specify what you want packed versus what you’ll pack yourself.
  • Confirm your preferred move dates and any flexibility you have.

This level of detail is what lets a mover give you a realistic number instead of a guess, and it’s the same information the FMCSA recommends having ready before you request a quote.

Getting estimates that are actually worth comparing

A phone quote is not an estimate. The FMCSA is explicit about this: a reputable mover inspects your belongings in person or gets a full, honest description of the inventory before giving you a number, and that number has to come in writing. A rate quoted over the phone without seeing what you own is a guess, not a commitment.

Once you have a written estimate, there are two kinds you’ll run into, and the difference matters at delivery. A binding estimate locks in the price based on the inventory you provided, and it only changes if you add items or services. A non-binding estimate is just that, an approximation, and under FMCSA rules on estimating charges, the mover can charge up to 110% of that estimated amount when your belongings are delivered.

To keep the comparison fair, give every company on your shortlist the identical scope:

  1. The same room-by-room inventory, including anything in storage units or outbuildings.
  2. The same move dates, or the same range of acceptable dates.
  3. The same access conditions: stairs, elevators, parking distance, long carries.
  4. The same packing scope, whether that’s full-service packing or just the heavy furniture.
  5. Any extra services you want included, like disassembly, storage, or specialty handling.

Pro Tip: Photograph high-value or fragile items before the move and keep a written inventory list with the estimate. If a dispute comes up later, dated photos and a matching inventory are far more persuasive than memory.

Estimates that don’t share this scope aren’t really comparable. A number that looks cheaper might simply be missing the packing labor another company included, and you won’t know until moving day.

Three estimates compared by included moving services

Checking who you’re actually hiring

A moving truck with a company’s logo on the side tells you very little on its own. What tells you more is whether that company is registered to do the work and whether other customers have filed complaints against it.

For interstate moves within the United States, the FMCSA requires a U.S. DOT number, and you can look that number up against the company’s advertised name to confirm it matches. USAGov also points consumers toward FMCSA resources for searching interstate movers and reviewing their complaint history before booking. For moves that stay within one state, licensing requirements vary by jurisdiction, so checking with your state’s consumer protection office is the equivalent step.

Before you sign anything, confirm these items directly with the company:

  • The U.S. DOT number, if the move is interstate, and that it matches the company’s name.
  • A real local address and working contact information, not just a booking hotline.
  • Written valuation and insurance terms, not a verbal assurance that you’re “covered.”
  • Any history of complaints through FMCSA’s database or your state consumer office.
  • Acceptable payment methods and whether a deposit is required before the move.

The FTC’s consumer alert on moving scams lists the warning signs that should make you walk away: blank paperwork, demands for a large deposit or cash only, and refusal to provide written terms. If a company won’t put its promises on paper, that reluctance is the answer you need. Reviews can supplement this process, since patterns of late delivery or damaged goods tend to show up repeatedly, but reviews alone never substitute for confirming registration and getting the contract in writing.

Questions to ask before you sign anything

A short conversation before you book can save you from a long dispute after you move. Ask every company on your shortlist the same set of questions, and insist the answers end up in writing rather than staying a verbal promise.

  • Who will actually perform the move, and does the company use subcontractors?
  • What’s included in the quoted price, and what’s billed separately?
  • How are stairs, elevators, long carries, and waiting time charged?
  • What happens to the price or schedule if your move date changes?
  • How does storage work if there’s a delay between pickup and delivery?
  • How do you file a claim if something is lost or damaged?

The FMCSA’s guidance on consumer rights is specific about why this matters: movers are required to give you information about your rights, the documents you should receive, and how to file complaints, and those protections only help you if you actually have the paperwork.

Two documents do the real work of protecting you. The order for service is what you sign when you book, and the bill of lading is the actual contract the driver gives you at pickup. Under FMCSA rules for household goods pickup, you’re entitled to copies of both, and the bill of lading has to include specific items: your valuation choice, acceptable payment methods, and the agreed inventory. Some orders include a right to cancel within a short window after signing, so ask your mover directly whether that applies to your contract.

Pro Tip: Keep every document from this process in one folder: the written estimate, the order for service, the inventory list, the bill of lading, and copies of any emails or texts. If a claim comes up, having everything in one place speeds up resolution considerably.

Before you finalize anything, ask to see the relevant tariff provisions that apply to your shipment and confirm which payment methods the company accepts. A company that hesitates to answer either question is telling you something.

What drives the final price, and where extra charges hide

The number on your initial quote is rarely the number you pay. Movers routinely add charges for services that weren’t itemized upfront, and knowing what those are ahead of time keeps you from being surprised at delivery.

Common add-ons include packing materials and labor, fuel or long-distance charges, stairs or long carry fees, elevator access, specialty handling for appliances or pianos, storage if there’s a gap between pickup and delivery, waiting time if you’re not ready when the truck arrives, and seasonal surcharges during peak moving months. If a dispute arises over any of these and you can’t resolve it directly with the mover, USAGov outlines how to escalate a complaint to the appropriate consumer protection office.

This is also where the binding versus non-binding distinction becomes real money. A non-binding estimate can grow as actual weight or services exceed what was described, and the mover is permitted to charge up to 110% of that estimate at delivery. A binding estimate avoids that growth entirely, as long as you didn’t add services along the way.

Here’s how that can play out with hypothetical quotes for the same move:

  1. Company A gives a non-binding quote based on a phone description with no in-person inspection.
  2. Company B gives a binding quote based on an inspector who walked through the home and cataloged every item.

If Company A’s actual weight comes in higher than described, the final bill could reach 110% of the estimate under the 110% rule, potentially approaching Company B’s fixed price, but without the certainty. For a detailed breakdown of what long-distance moves typically run, our moving costs breakdown covers typical ranges in more depth.

A signed written estimate is the strongest protection you have against this kind of creep: the FMCSA requires movers to provide one before your belongings are loaded, and a verbal rate quote never counts as a substitute.

Weighing documentation, valuation, schedule, and price

Once you have a few real estimates in hand, you need a way to decide between them that isn’t just “whoever’s cheapest.” A simple order of priorities helps you compare offers that look different on paper but serve the same job.

  • Put documentation and willingness to inspect first: a mover who skips the walkthrough is more likely to surprise you later.
  • Put valuation coverage second, especially if you own anything irreplaceable or expensive; understanding cargo insurance can help you decide on the right protection for your belongings.
  • Put schedule and communication third: a mover who’s vague about delivery windows is a mover who’s hard to reach when something goes wrong.
  • Put price last, after the first three are settled, since the cheapest quote that’s missing documentation or valuation clarity usually isn’t actually cheaper.

Not every move needs full-service help. If you’re comfortable loading and unloading yourself, labor-only movers or a self-service container can cost less and still get heavy items handled safely. Full-service moving costs more but covers packing, loading, transport, unloading, and often storage and specialty handling in one contract, which matters more for larger households, tight timelines, or anyone who simply doesn’t want to manage the logistics themselves.

When you’re down to final offers, a few practical rules can help you choose: pick the company that sent someone to inspect or reviewed a complete inventory, pick the one that explained valuation options in writing rather than a verbal “you’re covered,” and be wary of any company asking for an unusually large deposit before the move. The FTC’s guidance on moving scams treats large upfront payments as one of the clearest warning signs in the industry.

What working with a dedicated crew taught us about trust

Working with a dedicated truck and crew changes how documentation and communication actually happen. Our dedicated crew provides personalized attention throughout the moving process.

That consistency is also why we lean so heavily on the checklist above. Clear communication and attention to detail aren’t paperwork for their own sake. They’re what let a crew actually deliver on the plan we agreed to.

If you’re evaluating any mover, not just us, use the steps in this guide: ask for the inspection, ask for the written valuation terms, and ask for the documents before you sign. That’s the difference between a move that goes smoothly and one that doesn’t.

— Steven

How we help you put this checklist into practice

We focus on clear communication and attention to detail throughout the moving process. Our one-crew model provides personalized attention throughout your move.

Caseys Movers

We offer a range of services that map to the moves described above:

When you request a written estimate from us, we can discuss your move and the services you need. Reach out through our full-service moving page to get a written estimate started. Reach out through our full-service moving page to get a written estimate started.

FAQ

How to get a free move?

A genuinely free move is uncommon unless a third party, such as an employer relocation benefit or a verified assistance program, is covering the cost. Treat any offer advertising a completely free move as a lead-generation tactic or a potential scam until you’ve confirmed the sponsor, eligibility, and full scope in writing, according to FTC guidance on moving scams.

Is starting a moving company a good idea?

Whether starting a moving company makes sense depends on factors well outside the scope of choosing a mover as a customer, including licensing, insurance, and local market demand. This guide focuses on how to evaluate and hire a moving company rather than how to start one.

Which is better, porter or packers movers?

The right choice depends on how much of the physical work you want to handle yourself versus hand off entirely. Labor-only or porter-style help costs less and suits people who can manage their own truck and transport, while full packing and moving services cost more but cover everything from boxing up belongings to final placement in your new home.

What is the cheapest best moving company?

There’s no single cheapest or best mover, because the lowest quote often omits packing, access charges, storage, or valuation coverage that another bid included. Compare written estimates built on the same inventory and scope, and weigh documentation and valuation clarity alongside price rather than price alone.

Sources

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Earn $25 for every completed move referral.